Legal defense fundA federal court has stayed BAM’s case, and the hearing on its subpoenas for the Publisher’s name is continued. Donate on GoFundMe → · About the fund
← All updates
The Salem case · Court record · November 17, 2026

BAM’s lawyer was “sidelined” when Ammon McNeff answered the Gormans. His letter calls the Salem sale “never legally completed”; BAM’s audited statements book it at a $42,619 gain.

Chrystal Law and Benjamin Gorman filed the letter on November 16, 2026, in their lawsuit over the store BAM took back in 2024. It went out over McNeff’s name on February 12, with no one from BAM’s law firm on the filed copy; six days later BAM’s lawyer wrote, “I have been sidelined on this as you know, but I will participate in any mediation, unless I’m asked to stand down (which has happened in the past at times).” The letter says ownership “never legally vested” in the Gormans, that BAM had asked them for $175,000 within 15 days, and that BAM “assumed” they wanted its offer with no agreement signed; the notice BAM’s law firm sent in 2024 asked for $97,393.70 in those 15 days. BAM’s lawyer called the two sides’ February 5 meeting “a Rule 408 protected conversation”; BAM’s complaint in another court puts an “extortionistic threat” in a “2/5/26 call” and puts the same quoted words in “an early 2025 communication.”

PRIMARY SOURCEExhibits A to G to the declaration of Sarah Elizabeth Spencer, the plaintiffs’ lawyer, and the declaration of Chrystal Law, served November 16, 2026, in BAMF Salem 1, LLC v. BAM Franchising, Inc., Utah Business and Chancery Court No. 260200029 (the filing). The plaintiffs chose the exhibits, and no answer from BAM is on any record this site has read.

CONFIRMEDBAM’s audited statements for 2023, Note 8: “On February 2, 2023 the Company sold BAMF Salem to an outside party” (September 27). BAM’s notice of termination of November 14, 2024, demanded $97,393.70 within 15 days (October 17).

The letter

The letter is dated February 12, 2026, runs seven pages and ends “Ammon McNeff, President.” It went from McNeff’s email address to the Gormans’ lawyer. The filed copy shows Matthew McNeff on the copy line and no one from BAM’s law firm; she declares it came “directly to me with copies to my clients.” Its first paragraph looks forward to “an informal resolution, hopefully without involving legal counsel and attendant costs and delays.”

McNeff is “a non-attorney,” the Gormans’ lawyer notes in her declaration. BAM’s disclosure documents list him as president of Legally Mine from January 2011 until 2020. In 2025 the Supreme Court of Ohio enjoined that company and his father, Daniel McNeff, from the unauthorized practice of law in Ohio, for conduct the bar’s complaint dated from about 2010 to 2021 (October 3).

BAM had a lawyer on the matter, Wm. Kelly Nash of Dentons Durham Jones Pinegar. On January 20 he wrote of the meeting the two sides were planning, “If I participate, which is doubtful.” On February 3 he wrote that such meetings “are typically between the contracting parties (though counsel may attend),” that “BAM expects counsel to play a minimal role, as I have previously indicated,” and that “I do not plan to attend, but will be available by phone should questions arise by BAM.” Six days after the letter went out, he answered the Gormans’ request for mediation (the filing):

An email paragraph: A mediation is fine (and the next step under the FA), but I believe a document exchange should occur ahead of time. I also understand that Ammon has reached out to your clients (through you) in response to your letter demand with additional information, clarifications and questoins. May I suggest that you review such with your clients, have them provide a further reply as to any factual disputes and copy me. If your clients are producing records, please copy me on such as well from this point forward. I have been sidelined on this as you know, but I will participate in any mediation, unless I’m asked to stand down (which has happened in the past at times). The exchange should help us narrow the issues for any mediation and associated briefing.
Wm. Kelly Nash to the Gormans’ lawyer, February 18, 2026, the second paragraph, from Exhibit D. Spelling as in the original.

“I have been sidelined on this as you know,” Nash wrote, “but I will participate in any mediation, unless I’m asked to stand down (which has happened in the past at times).” He does not say who sidelined him, or why. His email opens, “I’ve been out since last Thursday,” which was February 12, the day of the letter. Of the letter he writes, “I also understand that Ammon has reached out to your clients (through you),” and he asks the Gormans’ lawyer to “please copy me” from then on. He proposes “a mutually agreeable date in mid March” for the mediation.

Over its seven pages the letter argues BAM’s case. It tells the Gormans they are “under a duty to preserve all evidence,” and calls what BAM took “assets properly seized and applied pursuant to BAMF’s contractual rights.” It asks for “all relevant books and records (i.e., documents, audio/video recordings, photographs, communications and/or other materials) in your possession,” says BAM “has a security interest” in them, and claims “a right of immediate possession.” On the evidence rule that covers settlement talks, it says: “we do not consider your 1/2/26 letter, this response thereto or your reply, if any, to be subject to Rule 408.”

BAM’s law firm had put the 15-day demand at $97,393.70. Phillip Kuck, then a lawyer at the same firm, signed the notice of termination on November 14, 2024, with a copy to Ammon McNeff (September 27). It lists three unpaid sums that total $97,393.70 (October 17) and leaves liquidated damages to a formula, with no figure. The letter over McNeff’s name says BAM “did not receive the $175,000 payment within 15 days as requested.”

The filings
PDFDeclaration of Sarah Elizabeth Spencer, with Exhibits A to JServed Nov. 16, 2026 · 72 pages · Exhibit A, the lawyers’ emails of January 9 to February 3, 2026; Exhibit C, the letter of February 12; Exhibits E and F, the emails of March 4 and March 23; Exhibit G, the call of November 14, 2024 · BAMF Salem 1, LLC v. BAM Franchising, Inc., No. 260200029 (Utah Bus. & Chancery Ct.)

The sale

On February 2, 2023, BAM sold its company-owned Salem store to Chrystal Law and Benjamin Gorman for $65,000. The purchase agreement calls for “a down payment of $20,000.00” and a note for “the remaining $45,000.00.” BAM’s audited statements record the sale at “a gain of $42,619” (September 27).

On November 14, 2024, BAM ended the franchise and took the store back. Its notice that night offered, in place of payment, to “assume ownership of the Salem, OR store” (August 19). Its verified complaint says it took the assets “as a bona fide purchaser” (August 8), having “exercised its priority rights to the collateral.” Its website calls Law “Owner of Salem, Oregon Location at the time.”

The February 12 letter tells the Gormans: “the sale of the store and its assets to you was never legally completed.” It says “ownership of the store assets never legally vested in you as purchasers,” and that on termination their “claim (and any right) to any beneficial use of the store and its assets reverted to BAMF.” The notice of termination had demanded, among its three sums, “the total balance of $48,893.75 for the purchase of franchise rights and the franchise territory” (October 17). On the call that night Ki McAllister, BAM’s Director of Operations, put it as “about $50,000 left on the original purchase of the store.”

The same letter says the notice invoked BAM’s right “to apply those assets as an offset against amounts owed to BAMF,” and that “BAMF’s offset fully absorbed those assets.”

The debt

November 14, 2024
The notice of termination
It demands $97,393.70 “within 15 days after the date of termination” (October 17). Liquidated damages are left to a formula, with no figure.
November 14, 2024
Ki McAllister, by phone that night
He says “these are not quoting exact numbers,” puts it at “$100,000 in damages” and tells the Gormans: “we’ll accept that we’re not gonna get that $100,000.”
February 12, 2026
The letter
“Salem owed roughly $175,000 to the franchisor (unpaid fees and liquidated damages) due within 15 days of termination.”
May 27, 2026
Two verified filings
Both say more than “an estimated $175,000.” For everything in the store, the complaint credits the Gormans “an estimated $38,000” (August 8); the motion, “an estimated $30,000.”
June 4, 2026
BAM’s website and press release
Its Salem timeline: she “owed just under $200,000 in unpaid royalties, unpaid lease, and covered vendor bills.” Its press release: “Chrystal Law/Gorman owed close to $200,000.”

The letter says the Gormans never paid an installment on the note, “BAMF never received any of the monthly installment payments from you,” and that the only payment plan on record covered royalties. The Gormans’ January 2 letter says BAM “accepted payments under that plan for months.” No payment ledger is among the filings this site has read.

The offer

BAM’s notice of termination recites “BAMF Salem 1, LLC’s subsequent agreement with BAM to surrender the franchise.” It then offered, in place of the $97,393.70, damages and fees, to take the store, its assets “and a waiver of all claims against BAM” (August 19), and asked for an answer: “If you are willing to agree to these terms, please so indicate and we will draft the proper documentation for the same.”

The February 12 letter says no agreement was signed. It says BAM “assumed (subject to verification) that you desired to accept BAMF’s offer ‘in lieu’ of the alternative,” and then that “the time to accept lapsed and your obligation remained in place.”

BAM’s website puts the debt inside an agreement: “An agreement was reached: she would hand over the store on November 14 smoothly, and BAM Corporate would not pursue the full $200,000 she owed. She agreed, giving her close to a week to prepare.”

On the night of the takeover, Ki McAllister told Benjamin Gorman by phone what BAM had decided: “Clean slate. You guys walk away. We walk away.” Gorman asked whether BAM had talked with Law that morning or at her. McAllister answered, “We talked at her,” then, “We sought to talk with her.”

February 5

UNRESOLVEDWhether the “2/5/26 call” in BAM’s complaint is the February 5 meeting. BAM’s own papers give the quoted words two dates, and the video BAM says it holds would show what was said at the meeting.

The two sides held the meeting Section 17 requires by videoconference on February 5, 2026, the Gormans’ lawyer declares (the filing). Two days earlier Nash wrote to the Gormans’ lawyer:

An email paragraph: BAM is confirmed for a 1:00 pm MST face to face settlement conference (or meeting) per the Franchise Agmt. It viewws it as a Rule 408 protected conversation, and hopes such will facilitate candor in the conversation and lead to a resolution of all issues.
Wm. Kelly Nash to the Gormans’ lawyer, February 3, 2026, the first paragraph, from Exhibit A. Spelling as in the original.

Rule 408 of the rules of evidence (federal, Utah) bars using statements made in settlement negotiations to prove or disprove a disputed claim; a court may admit them for another purpose.

A week after the meeting, the letter over McNeff’s name said “Matt and I felt progress was made” and called the video of it “the Rule 408 meeting recording.” BAM says the file is “approximately 422MB,” and its letter and both emails offer to send it once the Gormans’ lawyer names a secure way to transfer it. McNeff promised it at the meeting and did not deliver it “during the meeting, that day, or in any reasonable period thereafter,” she declares.

On May 27, BAM’s complaint in the Fourth District Court (the case), verified by Ammon McNeff, said: “In a 2/5/26 call with BAM as part of an attempted dispute resolution, Chrystal and Benjamin threatened that if BAM did not pay their demand for $300,000,” they “would not be able to control the ‘documentarian’ Schneider from releasing damaging (and doctored) videos harming the company.” It calls that an “extortionistic threat.”

The same complaint uses the same quoted sentence and the same $300,000 at paragraph 172, in “an early 2025 communication” that it attributes to “Bryan and Chrystal” (the census). BAM’s motion for a restraining order, signed by Nash the same day, keeps the 2/5/26 call and names “Chrystal, Benjamin and Bryan.” Paragraph 88 puts a “veiled threat” about Schneider, with no sum, in “BAM and Chrystal’s face-to-face meeting.”

The February 12 letter, written a week after the meeting, mentions no $300,000 demand. It objects to “implied or explicit threats of reputational harm or third-party interference.” The day after the complaint was filed, Matthew McNeff, introduced on a public livestream as “the COO of BAM,” read a statement about the restraining order a court had just granted BAM. It added, “as an additional observation,” that “following a face-to-face settlement meeting with [Chrystal] and Benjamin several months ago on February 6th, BAM expressly requested that she produce any and all evidence in her possession” (one hour and 52 minutes in). What it says of the meeting is that BAM asked for evidence and got none. It names no demand and no threat there, and it refers viewers to “the verified complaints on file.”

The Gormans’ January 2 letter, which BAM attached to its own motion, names no $300,000. It values the inventory and equipment taken at “over $100,000” and the consigned collection at “approximately $200,000,” and says in all “the damages exceed $750,000.” The letter does not add the first two figures; added here, they come to about $300,000.

November 14, 2024

Chrystal Law declares, under criminal penalty, that two images from the store’s cameras stamped 7:12 p.m. show Brandon Best inside the store after closing, and that from her review of the footage he stayed until at least 8:34 p.m. She declares that earlier that day she “was told only that someone would be coming to look at the store,” and that at about 7:57 p.m. she said on video in the store, “And I still haven’t. You might want to let them know to send me that email.” The notice of termination came by email from BAM’s law firm later that night. Her declaration names no time zone; the store is in Oregon, on Pacific time.

BAM’s complaint calls Best “BAM’s representative” and says he “was engaged as a contracted inventory inspector for BAM.” He and Josh Johnson later took over the store as Baker Bricks. Johnson said of the takeover in September: “So we got Salem for free, right?” (October 24).

On the recorded call that evening, McAllister said of a call with Law earlier in the day: “I will acknowledge that it seems like the message wasn’t quite got across that, that we were trying to convey. I apologize for that, but we did convey that there was gonna be a termination in that, that Brandon was going to come over today, umm, to, umm, take over the store.” He told Gorman: “Ultimately, if you guys have not reached out telling us about you looking to move out of the country, you still would have gotten a termination.” The call’s line “It sounds like a threat” has been on this site since August (August 15). The transcript is now in the court file.

Mentioned in the papers, not attached

The fair reading, and its limit. A company may speak through its president, and the record does not say who drafted the letter. The Ohio consent decree named Legally Mine and Daniel McNeff, not Ammon McNeff; BAM’s documents end his office there in 2020. The purchase agreement made the landlord’s consent a condition of closing. The Gormans’ account has moved on the price and who threatened them, Law was in the store with Best that evening, and BAM’s complaint puts a threat at the meeting. The limit: BAM booked the sale its president says never completed, its law firm’s notice asked for $97,393.70 in 15 days where he says $175,000 was requested, and one quoted sentence carries two dates.

The record

The November 16 filing. The audited sale and the notice of termination. Six valuations of one store. The $65,000 sale. The clause that erases you. The census, paragraphs 90 and 172. The takedown. Legally Mine and Ohio’s board.

Sources. Declaration of Sarah Elizabeth Spencer, paragraphs 6, 7, 10, 11 and 16 and Exhibits A, C, D, E, F and G, and Declaration of Chrystal Law, paragraphs 4 to 9, BAMF Salem 1, LLC v. BAM Franchising, Inc., No. 260200029 (Utah Bus. & Chancery Ct., served Nov. 16, 2026), the first linked above. BAM Franchising, Inc.’s Verified Motion to Stay and to Compel Mediation and Then Arbitration, May 27, 2026, paragraphs 5 and 6, and its Exhibit 1, the Gormans’ letter of January 2, 2026. Notice of Immediate Termination, November 14, 2024, and Business and Asset Purchase Agreement, February 2, 2023, Exhibits D and C to the Salem complaint. Verified Complaint, BAM Franchising, Inc. v. Schneider, No. 260402353 (Utah 4th Dist. Ct., filed May 27, 2026), paragraphs 25, 27 to 29, 41, 88, 90 and 172 and its verification, and the plaintiffs’ motion for a temporary restraining order of the same date, page 27. BAM’s audited financial statements for 2023, Note 8, in its 2024 franchise disclosure document. BAM’s Salem store timeline and press release of June 4, 2026. A livestream published by ACOB on YouTube, May 28, 2026. BAM’s franchise disclosure documents, Item 2: the edition issued April 30, 2021 (“since January 2011”) and the editions of 2022 to 2026 (“since January 2011 until 2020”). Ohio State Bar Assn. v. Legally Mine, L.L.C., 2025-Ohio-539. The right of reply is open to everyone named here.

← NewerAll updatesOlder →

Home · Map · The law · Bodycam · Coverage