Chrystal Law and Benjamin Gorman put the emails in the court file on November 16, 2026, in answer to BAM’s motion to move their lawsuit over the Salem, Oregon, store out of open court and into confidential arbitration. Their lawyer asked for “formal mediation with a neutral mediator” on February 11; BAM’s own lawyer called mediation “the next step under the FA” and wrote in the same email, “I have been sidelined on this as you know, but I will participate in any mediation, unless I’m asked to stand down (which has happened in the past at times).” BAM, which wants arbitration, has filed no demand for one with the American Arbitration Association, to the knowledge of the Gormans’ lawyer; its motion says it “has no affirmative obligation” to. The two sides mediated on October 20 with no order, and the case did not settle, the Gormans’ filings say.
PRIMARY SOURCEPlaintiffs’ Memorandum in Opposition to Defendant’s Verified Motion to Stay and to Compel Mediation and Then Arbitration, with the declarations of Sarah Elizabeth Spencer, the plaintiffs’ lawyer, and Chrystal Law, served November 16, 2026, in BAMF Salem 1, LLC v. BAM Franchising, Inc., Utah Business and Chancery Court No. 260200029; and BAM’s verified motion of May 27, 2026.
CONFIRMEDOn May 27, 2026, BAM filed two papers in two Utah courts: its motion in the Salem case and its own complaint in the Fourth District. Ammon McNeff verified both.
AS STATEDThe Gormans chose the exhibits, and the account of the October 20 mediation is theirs (November 4). No reply from BAM is on any record this site has read.
BAM’s motion of May 27, 2026, asks the court to stay the Gormans’ lawsuit and “compel the parties to timely mediate and, if necessary, arbitrate this dispute.” It tells the court: “Though expressly requested by BAM, Plaintiffs have refused to produce requested records relating to and to engage in a good faith mediation.”
Wm. Kelly Nash of Dentons Durham Jones Pinegar signed it for BAM. Ammon McNeff verified it: “I have read the foregoing assertions and believe them to be true and accurate to the best of my knowledge and belief.”
The Gormans’ request for mediation went to Nash, who signed the motion. In the email where he wrote that he had been sidelined, he said he had been “out since last Thursday,” the day of McNeff’s letter, that he understood “Ammon has reached out to your clients (through you),” and asked the Gormans’ lawyer to “please copy me” on any records her clients produced. On February 3 he had written that “BAM expects counsel to play a minimal role” at the two sides’ meeting. The February 18 email does not say who sidelined him, or why. McNeff is “a non-attorney,” she notes in her declaration. The filed copies of his letter and his two emails show them going to her, with Matthew McNeff on the copy line and no one from BAM’s law firm.
Section 17 of the franchise agreement “does not require, as a condition of mediation, the production of documents or evidence by either party,” the Gormans’ lawyer declares.
BAM has filed no arbitration demand either, to the knowledge of the Gormans’ lawyer. She declares: “To my knowledge, Defendant has never filed a demand for mediation or for arbitration with the American Arbitration Association with respect to any claim between the parties.” BAM’s motion says: “BAM has no affirmative obligation to demand or initiate an arbitration against Plaintiffs. BAM has never initiated any claims against Plaintiffs.”
McNeff verified a second paper on May 27. BAM, both McNeffs, Josh Johnson, Brandon Best and Baker Bricks sued Benjamin Schneider, Bryan Mansell and others in Utah’s Fourth District Court (the case). It does not name Law or Gorman as defendants. It says Schneider, his company and their affiliates “conspired together and with co-Defendants and Chrystal Law (‘Chrystal’) and Benjamin Gorman (‘Benjamin’) (also potential DOE 1-15 defendants).”
The two papers McNeff verified that day do not agree on who asked for the February meeting. The complaint says “BAM proposed a face-to-face meeting.” The motion says the parties “held the face-to-face meeting requested by Plaintiffs.” The Gormans’ lawyer had demanded it on January 2, in a letter BAM attached to the motion.
On the takeover, the complaint says BAM “exercised its priority rights to the collateral in the Security Agreement, pre-scheduled a repossession with Chrystal and repossessed the Salem LLC store.” The motion says BAM “repossessed the Salem LLC store and assets, and assumed the lease, as expressly permitted under the FA and APA.” Both rest the takeover on BAM’s contracts, and neither names a court order. The Gormans’ memorandum says BAM then “chose a court, not the AAA, for its own claims” about the store: “BAM cannot claim the exclusion for itself and deny it to the party across the table.”
The exclusion is in BAM’s own form. Section 17.A sends disputes to mediation and arbitration “except as expressly provided below,” and Section 17.A(4) says the agreement “does not obligate them to mediate or arbitrate claims or issues relating primarily to” four numbered subjects. The second is “Franchisor’s rights to obtain possession of any real and personal property (including any action in unlawful detainer, ejectment or otherwise).” After the fourth item’s closing parenthesis come a comma and, with no numeral, the words “intentional interruption by Franchisee or Franchisor of business operations with the exception of the provisions of Section 14 relating to Breaches, Defaults or Termination.”
The Gormans say both describe what BAM did: “BAM’s agent entering Plaintiffs’ store after hours on November 14, 2024, changing the locks, and taking everything inside, down to customers’ layaway property and consigned goods, before any notice of termination was sent.” Their memorandum says “Nothing in Section 14 authorizes BAM to enter a franchisee’s store, change the locks, or take inventory, fixtures, cash, records, or customer property,” and that the agreement’s only way for BAM to acquire a terminated franchisee’s assets is the appraisal and purchase in Section 15.E, “which BAM never used.” It closes: “BAM entered Plaintiffs’ store at night, took everything in it, and now says it had the right to. That is the case the parties kept in court.”
The Gormans argue that the court, not an arbitrator, decides what the clause covers, and quote the statute: “The court shall decide whether an agreement to arbitrate exists or a controversy is subject to an agreement to arbitrate” (Utah Code 78B-11-107). BAM’s motion cites the same section on another point and grants that “a court may decide whether an agreement to arbitrate ‘exists’ or whether a controversy is subject to an agreement to arbitrate.” This site described carve-outs of this kind in July (July 5).
If BAM wins the motion, the dispute goes to the American Arbitration Association in Utah County, where under Section 17 “the parties to any mediation/arbitration will execute appropriate confidentiality agreements, excepting only such public disclosures and filings as required by law.”
If the Gormans win, the case stays in open court, and so does their pending request to add Ammon McNeff, Matthew McNeff, Brandon Best, Josh Johnson, Baker Bricks and Salem-Baker Bricks as defendants and to plead a Utah racketeering count (the amendment). None of the six is a party to the franchise agreement, their memorandum says.
Neither motion had been decided when the Gormans filed. BAM may reply under Rule 7 of the Utah Rules of Civil Procedure, and the Gormans have asked for a hearing. BAM’s response to the motion to amend, proposed for the same day (November 4), is not among the filings this site has read.
The fair reading, and its limit. BAM’s lawyer proposed an exchange of records in January, and BAM said it would mediate once it had the Gormans’ records; their exhibits show no answer from their side after February 11. Their January letter named mediation and arbitration as next steps. A company may speak through its president. BAM reads “intentional interruption” as an example under the fourth item, “not set off by a separate numeral,” and says “the Section 14 exception would carve these claims back into arbitration.” The limit: the Gormans asked in writing, BAM’s lawyer called mediation the next step, and BAM’s president wrote that its cost could be avoided before verifying that they refused it.
The November 3 status report. The court’s date and the docket. The amended complaint. The $65,000 sale. Five tools Utah law gives a terminated franchisee. The takedown.
Sources. Plaintiffs’ Memorandum in Opposition to Defendant’s Verified Motion to Stay and to Compel Mediation and Then Arbitration; Declaration of Sarah Elizabeth Spencer, paragraphs 10, 11, 14, 15 and 24 and Exhibits A to F; Declaration of Chrystal Law; all in BAMF Salem 1, LLC v. BAM Franchising, Inc., No. 260200029 (Utah Bus. & Chancery Ct., served Nov. 16, 2026), the first two linked above. BAM Franchising, Inc.’s Verified Motion to Stay and to Compel Mediation and Then Arbitration, May 27, 2026: its introduction, paragraphs 6 and 10, its second, third and fourth arguments, its conclusion, its signature block, its verification, and its Exhibit 1, the Gormans’ letter of January 2, 2026. Verified Complaint, BAM Franchising, Inc. v. Schneider, No. 260402353 (Utah 4th Dist. Ct., filed May 27, 2026), paragraphs 9, 27 and 87 and its verification. The franchise agreement, Exhibit B to the Salem complaint, Section 17. The right of reply is open to everyone named here.